Lib Dem leader Ed Davey refuses six times to say whether coalition-era austerity was a mistake

Sir Ed Davey has refused six times to say whether austerity was a mistake in an interview with Sky News.

The Liberal Democrat leader also specifically denied that the austerity policies his party implemented alongside the Conservatives were to blame for the current crisis facing the NHS – which he is promising to “save” if his party wins power on 4 July.

In an interview with Sky News deputy political editor Sam Coates, he said the “real, big problems” facing the health service began under the Conservatives in 2015, when the coalition between David Cameron and Nick Clegg came to an end.

But challenged on whether the reorganisation of the NHS that happened on his watch was to blame for the current crisis facing the health service, Sir Ed said: “I think the Conservatives have been in power for last nine years and they failed.”

General election live: Follow the latest updates

The Lib Dems, led by Nick Clegg, entered into a coalition with David Cameron’s Conservatives in the 2010 election until the latter secured a slim majority in the subsequent 2015 election.

During that time, the coalition implemented austerity policies that slashed public expenditure following the 2008 financial crisis, with the NHS one of a number of services hit.

Analysis: Why Lib Dems’ manifesto is far less ambitious than previous one

A King’s Fund report in April found the health service had “declined since 2010, as a result of much lower funding increases, limited funds for capital investment and neglect of workforce planning”.

A number of Lib Dem politicians – including former business secretary Sir Vince Cable and former leader Jo Swinson – have expressed regret for austerity and conceded that it may have cost them votes in the 2015 election, when the party was reduced to just eight MPs.

In her conference speech in 2018, Ms Swinson – who was a junior minister in the coalition government – told Lib Dem members: “Negotiating with the Conservatives meant compromise and some of those compromises sucked. We should have done more.”

Manifesto to ‘save’ the NHS

Sir Ed has put the pledge to “save” the NHS and fix social care at the heart of his election manifesto, which was published today.

The party leader said the Liberal Democrats would spend £9bn fixing the health and social care system, including plans to recruit 8,000 more GPs, the right to see a GP within seven days, and a boost cancer survival rates.

He said it was “a manifesto to save the NHS”.

But asked by Coates whether such promises to fix the NHS and social care were needed only to repair issues caused by the coalition, Sir Ed argued his party pushed for measures on care for the elderly and disabled people when in office, but the Tories “broke their promises”.

“When the Tories were by themselves, they took an absolute axe to some of the poorest people in our country, and that was absolutely shocking,” he said.

Questions still linger about Sir Ed Davey’s coalition past

Sam Coates

Deputy political editor

@SamCoatesSky

Rather like Sir Keir Starmer, Sir Ed Davey inherited a thoroughly broken party in 2020 when he became leader.

Also rather like Sir Keir, if the polls and polling projections are to be believed, Sir Ed has brought the party to the brink of a remarkable comeback, reversing the deep losses bequeathed by Nick Clegg in 2015 after five years of coalition.

The made-for-TV election stunts may look bold, but Sir Ed’s plan has been cautious and incremental.

Nothing bold on Brexit, which was the signature of the party’s 2019 campaign. No pretence that Sir Ed could be prime minister after the election, as Jo Swinson pretended in 2019 – this is a campaign targeted in seats the party thinks it can win.

Instead we have a campaign of reassurance from a party that abandoned “equidistance” – holding Labour and Tory at similar distance which led to five years of coalition with the Tories until 2015 – and turning them into a purely anti-Tory force, more in tune with many activists’ inclinations.

Now the party could be about to quadruple its seats. This could put it on course to returning as the third biggest party in the Commons, regaining the crown from the ailing Scottish National Party, its biggest achievable goal for the 4 July election.

Yet Sir Ed has brought the Lib Dems to this point while leaving unresolved some big questions about both the past and the future.

“And I am really proud that we managed to stop them for so long.”

👉 Tap here to follow Politics at Jack at Sam’s wherever you get your podcasts 👈

Pushed again over his refusal to say if he endorsed the decisions made by the coalition, the Lib Dem leader replied: “Well, I’m telling you Sam, I fought Conservatives every day and in this election I’ve made it clear there is no way we will allow the Conservatives back into office.

“They are out of ideas and excuses and need to be out of office. Every vote for a Liberal Democrat will be a vote for a great champion to put forward those policies to rescue our NHS and to get the Conservatives out of government.”

As well as the NHS, social care has also been placed front and centre of Sir Ed’s pitch to voters.

The Liberal Democrat leader has spoken candidly of his experience caring for his disabled son and, as a child, looking after his terminally ill mother.

He said his manifesto is the first in the party’s history to include a dedicated chapter on care, with pledges including free personal care for the elderly and the disabled and a higher salary for care workers, set £2 above the minimum wage.